The Truth About Icing: Helping Young Athletes Recover Smarter Between Practices and Races

For decades, icing has been the go-to recovery ritual after hard practices and meets. Parents grab ice packs while professional athletes step into cold plunges. But what does science actually say about how and when icing helps the body recover—and when it might not be needed?

What Happens When We Ice

When muscles are cooled after intense exercise, blood vessels constrict, circulation slows, and tissue temperature drops. This limits swelling and dulls pain signals. Research shows that cooling muscles within the first hour after exercise can reduce delayed-onset muscle soreness and fatigue in the short term. For track athletes training or competing on consecutive days, that short-term relief can make a real difference in performance readiness.

However, consistent use after every workout may slightly reduce long-term training gains. Some studies have shown that routine cold-water immersion can blunt the molecular signals that trigger muscle growth and repair. In other words, icing should be viewed as a short-term recovery tool, not a daily ritual—especially when the goal is to build strength and endurance.

Icing Later: 12–24 Hours After Exercise

If you miss that first hour, icing can still help. At this point, inflammation has already peaked, but cold exposure can still reduce residual soreness, calm the nervous system, and promote better sleep quality. Recent research has found that delayed cold therapy can improve perceived recovery and reduce muscle stiffness even after the main inflammatory phase has passed. Think of it as a nervous-system reset more than an anti-inflammatory effect.

Youth Athletes Recover Differently

Kids and teens naturally recover faster. Their tissues are more elastic, and their systems are quick to repair small amounts of muscle soreness. For young athletes, icing should be used after long meets, hard interval sessions, or when swelling is visible—not after every light practice. Over-icing can actually reduce blood flow that’s needed for normal growth and healing around developing joints. In most cases, simple recovery strategies like movement, hydration, stretching, and good sleep go further than daily icing.

Ice Bath or Ice Pack?

You don’t need a fancy setup or expensive cold plunge to get results. A bag of ice, a bucket of cold water, or a frozen water bottle can be just as effective. Ice baths are best for cooling larger muscle groups after intense sessions or competitions, while ice packs are perfect for localized areas like knees, ankles, or shins. Aim for 10–15 minutes, and let the skin warm fully before reapplying if needed.

When Icing Isn’t Needed

If the body feels tight or fatigued but not sore or swollen, skip the ice. Gentle stretching, light aerobic movement, and mobility work are often more effective for restoring normal motion and reducing stiffness. Icing is best seen as a recovery tool, not a default step after every workout.

The Takeaway for Parents

Cold therapy can help young athletes feel better faster when used wisely. Icing within the first hour after an intense workout reduces soreness and inflammation, while icing later can still calm the body and promote rest. But the most important recovery tools will always be movement, nutrition, hydration, and sleep. Use icing as one piece of a balanced recovery plan—not the whole plan itself.

---

References

1. Bleakley CM, et al. “Cooling interventions for the prevention and treatment of exercise-induced muscle damage: a systematic review with meta-analysis.” Br J Sports Med. 2012;46(4):233–240.

2. Yamane M, et al. “Effect of post-exercise muscle cooling on recovery of muscle strength following strenuous resistance training.” J Physiol Sci. 2015;65(6):559–566.

3. Roberts LA, et al. “Post-exercise cold water immersion attenuates acute anabolic signaling and long-term adaptations in muscle to strength training.” J Appl Physiol. 2015;118(6):603–610.

4. White GE, et al. “Cold-water immersion and other forms of cryotherapy: physiological changes potentially affecting recovery from high-intensity exercise.” Sports Med. 2021;51(3):501–515.

---

Coach Jamar combines elite athletic experience with advanced clinical expertise as both a Doctor of Physical Therapy and owner of KinoFit Physical Therapy as well as a Sprints & Hurdles Coach at 813 Elite. He’s passionate about helping athletes move better, recover smarter, and perform at their highest potential.